Transgender Day of Remembrance

Share this page...

Speaker & Worship Leader:- Maria Hayward,

with Rachel Mackintosh, Tess Brothersen, Ted Zorn, Betsy Marshall

This service is to both commemorate those killed due to anti-transgender hatred or prejudice, as well as to raise visibility of the transgender community and the issues they face.

It will be an emotional service, that will tell stories, debunk myths and provide information. There will be prizes, ribbons and celebratory elements too!

Bring your rainbow friends so we can show our support and allyship.

Video to come

Audio to come

Follow this shortcut to the bottom of the page for the various readings, videos, etc. shared in the service.

Read below, or download the PDF – to come


Maria Hayward © 15 November 2026

Opening words

Today we commemorate Transgender Day of Remembrance (which is on November 20th) and also Transgender Awareness Month. Additionally, today is Intersex Awareness Day and many intersex people identify as trans – so let’s think about this minority group today as well.

Transgender Day of Remembrance (TDoR) was initiated in 1999, tohonour a black American transgender woman, Rita Hester, who was murdered in 1998. Today, TDoR commemorates transgender people around the world, who were killed in hate crimes during the preceding year. Some of these murders are known about, most are not. The day is also an opportunity for raising visibility of the transgender community, for learning about the issues they face, and for seeing their humanity.

This has been a difficult service for me to write and may also be difficult for me to deliver. The commemoration affects me personally because I have a very lovely, kind, gentle and wonderful transgender daughter who has already met some of the terrible statistics which I will mention today.

It is hard for me to have to research these statistics, to discover how every year, hate speech and violence against the trans community, increases. This is especially the case for transwomen. Which potentially makes my daughter’s life more dangerous and she has done nothing wrong.

We have, and have had, transgender people in this church. Today, I think, is the day we show support for everyone in the transgender whanau – parents, siblings, allies, partners – but most especially for trans people themselves.

Name reading:

We will take a few minutes now to honour all the transgender people murdered in the last 12 months.

The Transgender Europe and Central Asia (TGEU) report has a list of 281 people murdered in hate crimes because of their gender identity. This is 281 known people. Many nations don’t count or report transgender deaths and many countries misgender or deadname (use the name given at birth) trans individuals at death, so their murders are not recorded as hate crimes.

Ninety percent of these murders were against trans women, and a significant number were black women. The number of trans murders in Europe has decreased over the last year, while in the USA, it has increased). Several trans activists are included in this number. Many of the deaths included torture, and several of those murdered were under the age of 30.

You were given a small yellow card on arrival, or there are some spare cards on seats. These cards have the first name and age (if known) of one of those 281 people. We will read them out in memory of all others around the world.

If you wish, please read out loudly the name and age (if given) from your card. If you do not wish to read the name, that is fine; simply signal to the person sitting next to you to read their name, or pass your card to them and they can read both if they wish.

Transgender Day of Remembrance

Kia ora koutou katoa. Let’s start with an understanding of the term transgender. A transgender person is someone whose internal sense of their gender does not match the gender assigned to them at birth.

The word itself didn’t enter English dictionaries till the 1990’s, although it had been coined some time earlier. I, myself, only encountered the term in the early 2000’s – when it was entering the common parlance. Previously, the term transvestite was used to describe adults who dressed as a gender not assigned at birth, or there was the term ‘transsexual’ which described someone who was living as a person with a different gender to that assigned at birth.

We just have the two words in English for genders: male and female, although, historically, we did use the pronoun ‘they’ as a gender-neutral pronoun for individuals of unknown or non-binary gender. In many other languages and cultures, there exist lots of words for a range of genders and sexualities, including transgender. At least 150 nations have linguistic terms or words for 3 or 4 genders and in one North America first nation language, there are 5 words for (5) different genders. Today, in English-speaking countries, we have a greater awareness of the many different ways human beings view their gender identity. And so, we now use terms such as gender fluid, non-binary, bigender, agender and of course, transgender.

Why does transness occur? We don’t really know, but many in the transgender community believe transness is biological, that is, that children are born trans – just like children are born gay or bisexual or intersex and so on.

Others feel that they have come to their trans identity through an exploration of gender and their understandings of themselves.

My daughter was about 4 years old when she came downstairs and told us she was not a boy, she was a girl. She was just 4. I said, “No, you’re a boy, and boys are great. We love boys. And we really love you”. Many years later I asked her if she remembered that conversation. She did recall it – very clearly. I might talk more about her later.

Humans have diverse ways of expressing the gendered aspects of their lives.

Gender dysphoria is when a person feels that their gender is other than that assigned at birth. It doesn’t matter what causes gender dysphoria, or how a person expresses their gender identity.

I want to be absolutely clear today: a transgender person is NOT someone who changes their gender because they want to be a different gender, they are the other gender and they want to change their physical presentation to be the gender that they, in their minds, the gender they were born with. And in my mind, as well as in the minds of health professionals in general.

A transwoman is a woman. A transman is a man.

Can we make this the takeaway number 1 from today’s talk. I’ll return to this later. Transitioning is not changing your gender – it is affirming it. I’ll repeat that: Transitioning is not changing your gender – it is affirming it.

My daughter was not alone in identifying her gender at age 4. In studies on transgenderism, some children as young as 2, have stated they knew at this very early age they were ‘different’. Most studies show that a large portion of transgender individuals experience initial gender dysphoria at about 7 years of age or younger. Within the category of transness, sit many intersex individuals, who have characteristics of both genders, and some choose one gender as their stronger gender – mainly for societal acceptance reasons, but also for personal survival reasons.

As I mentioned last year, there is a new intolerance for transgenderismand the hate rhetoric has consequences. I also mentioned some sobering, but tragic statistics. I’ve researched an update of these, but they’re very similar to last year, which is that in Aotearoa/NZ:

  • Just under 1% of adults over 15 years, identify as trans or non-binary
  • 66.5% of trans people have faced discrimination
  • 1 in 10 have experienced deliberate violence
  • 50% have self-harmed
  • 53% report suicidal ideation
  • Up to 42% have attempted suicide (though this figure varies from year to year)

My daughter figures in this statistic. She has attempted suicide 4 times, the first, which actually I don’t count is this number as it was feeble attempt – was when she was 8 years old. I found her in her room with a noose around her neck. This was honestly the most gorgeous and loved child in the world – just like all of your kids. I’ll tell you what she told me about this event later.

There has been a four-fold increase in transphobic hatecrimes over the last five-six years – four-fold – (particularly following trans-bashing from politicians and anti-trans public speakers).

So, what can we, as Unitarians,do to stem this tide of hatred and violence towards the transgender community? And how can we, turn our Kaupapa (our principles and values) of diversity and inclusion, into action?

As I said last year, being well-informed is really important so that we can refute the myths perpetrated by anti-trans activists and others.

Tess and I are going to look at the key anti-trans myths now. Before we do, I have a precursor I’d like to mention. Last year someone asked me after our service why I had focused only on transwomen. I went home and re-read my notes. The beginning of my talk was like the one today – non-gender specific, but then when I went over the myths – it was indeed true, that these myths focused mostly on transwomen. So, I thought it might be useful to mention beforehand that most of the myths and the hate speech is directed just at trans women. I do want to stress, however, that the journey for trans males is also extremely difficult.

Ok, so on with the myths: last year I discussed 4 myths, this year I have 10!!

We’re going to play good cop and bad cop now. Two bad cops will read the myths and Tess and I will play the good cops – we’ll rebut the myths.

Myth 1: female toilets are unsafe when shared with transwomen.

This contention has no links to reality or to science. There is not one piece of evidence that a single cis-gender (non-trans) woman has ever, anywhere in the world, been attacked by a trans woman in a public toilet. Indeed, trans people are far more likely to suffer harm in public spaces.

As you will know, the biggest danger to women today, is actually men in their own homes!

Myth 2: Education programmes that teach about different sexualities and gender identification somehow encourage or brainwash young people to become trans, non-binary or even gay etc.

The NZ Ministry of Education has been directed to remove guidelines that werein the previous Relationships and Sexuality Education (RSE) programmes. In short, schools are now not allowed to mention that there are different gender identities, like trans or non-binary. So, how are these kids ever going to know how to talk about their terrifying feelings?

When I asked my adult daughter, why she, at age 8, steadfastly and totally refused to come and talk to the child psychologist with whom I had made an appointment following the incident I mentioned earlier; my daughter said “I knew there was something different about me. I didn’t know what it was. I thought there was something very wrong with me and I knew enough about counsellors and psychologists to know that they would likely drag this out of my mouth. And I was so afraid, I was so afraid of the big, scarey thing in me that I couldn’t name, that they would elicit from me.” And she added: “I felt a disconnect with the outside world, and this was deeply disturbing for me, but I couldn’t identify what it was, I couldn’t describe it. I just knew it was a big thing.”

She didn’t have the words (and nor did we) to express or name what she was feeling. If there had been a school programme that had given her the language and understanding about different forms of gender identity and sexuality, she would have had the words. She would been spared years of grief, anxiety and trauma, and we, as her parents, would have known better ways to support her. Young people have a right to know the language to talk about themselves and they have a right to be themselves. The denial of truth and science in education is very dangerous.

Myth 3: (connected to the myth that young people learn to be trans) and this myth is that people choose to be trans.

I have to ask, who would choose prejudice, bigotry, hate, ridicule and danger?  Seriously!!!. Who chooses social exclusion, social hatred, mockery and the likelihood of violence towards themselves?

Myth 4: “there are only 2 genders – there is no science that there are more”.

Well, there is science, actually, and there is also the census data from many countries which show the existence of a wide variety of gender identification, including up to 1.5% of individuals who identify as trans. Historical, linguistic and social evidence is there. The number of intersex people is the same as the number of red-haired people in the world. And intersex conditions, like transgender characteristics (and same gender attraction, actually) also occur across a wide variety of species, including mammals, fish and birds.

Why does it concern politicians, some religious people and others that people and animals are different and diverse? IT JUST DOESN’T MATTER! (Takeaway number two from today’s service)

Myth 5: the myth about trans women in sport. The myth that: “It’s not fair. Transwomen have an advantage over non-trans sportswomen”.

I’m going to repeat what I said last year about the science regarding transwomen in sport.

Although research in this area is limited, in general, the consensus is that hormone treatment actually decreases rather than enhances performance for transgender women. One study did find that trans women retained a residual small advantage in running speed, but several other studies contradicted this and actually showed that feminizing gender affirming hormone therapy (GAHT) led to significant declines in speed, and in strength as well as endurance in transgender women.Furthermore, other studies have found that, relative to body mass, transgender women have lower cardiovascular fitness compared to cisgender women, which can negatively impact speed, recovery, and endurance.

There’s this bull**** thing that “men are trying to join women in their sports and competitions” – but transwomen are not men, they are women.

Trans sportswomen have no advantage whatsoever and transgender women are actually under-represented per capita at the elite level and have not dominated women’s sports.

Myth 6: Transgenderism is a mental disorder (the brain is mentally unwell for telling us their body is wrong).

People used the mental health argument about gay people too. Well, the World Health Organisation deemed back in 2019 that transgenderism is NOT a mental health condition. It is a condition just like infertility is a condition. It is real. The WHO acknowledged that it has been present across history and across cultures. Some examples of transgender existence in world cultures: include: the Hijra in South Asia, the two-spirit people in indigenous USA, the fafa’fine in Samoa, takatapui in Aotearoa, and the “New Half” people in Japan. Colonising Christian missionaries unable to cope with this phenomenon, killed non-gender conforming individuals in the Americas, Africa and Asia and forced people into 2 gender roles.

Myth 7: Trans-inclusive spaces are unsafe for women.

Number one, trans women are women. Number two – again, there is not a skirret, not a single piece of evidence of any danger to anyone posed by a transgender person in a women-only space – not one attack, not one instance of danger to others. But there are hundreds and thousands of instances of heterosexual men attacking or threatening women – virtually everywhere. Finally, it is transwomen who are unsafe in most spaces in many, many countries.

Myth 8: Lots of transgender people ‘change their mind’ and de-transition.

Although it is true that some people do go back to their gender assigned at birth, the number is very, very small. And yes, there has been some research into why this is – and the research has found that this cohort say that their life as a transgender person was too difficult – either in the workplace or in their home (the latter was especially the case for individuals with strong fundamentalist church connections) – and so they de-transition. Most comment on massive external pressure to do so.

Myth 9: It is risky for kids to get hormone treatment.

In fact, non-trans young people have been getting hormone treatment (puberty blockers) for decades – with no detrimental side effects. If transgender people do not get hormone treatment, the consequences are very dangerous and risky – remember that statistic of 42% suicide rate.

Myth 10: Puberty blockers just make kids become trans before they are old enough.

It was mentioned earlier that kids know at a young age that they are a different gender from that assigned at birth. Puberty blockers don’t make kids trans. Quite the opposite. They enable them to NOT transition early and this gives them a period of time, to consider their life choices. During this period, their bodies don’t change, so if they do want to transition as young adults, it will be much less expensive, dramatic, traumatic and stressful. We know that there is 73% less suicidal ideation once kids are on puberty blockers. It literally saves lives. And they’re not dangerous – medical professionals are trying to shout this as loudly as they can. They have been used with young people for many decades – mainly for kids who reach puberty too early.

Trans Allies: Ok, so what can you do if you wish to support the rights of trans people?

  1. Try to remember the arguments that debunk the myths so that you can respond calmly, with facts, when people raise these invalid concerns.
  2. Write submissions when governments try to introduce laws that restrict or remove the rights of minority groups.
  3. If you are unclear, check the facts. Find the science or the research.
  4. Put on your compassionate hats. And put yourselves in the shoes of people who are being targeted. Then, stand alongside them.
  5. Don’t say nothing. Stand up for oppressed groups.

We, as UU’s, may consider it important, as a caring community, to think about all minority groups who are oppressed – we state this in our principles and in our values. Today we have been thinking about transgender people. The hundreds who have died and will die in the next 12 months. Deaths that would not have happened in a world where minorities were valued and included and loved. And the tens of thousands of transgender people worldwide who live in constant fear of hatred, violence, mockery, rejection and discrimination. Simply because of their gender identity.

Pledge

To conclude, Tess and I have a message for the transgender, intersex, nonbinary and gender-expansive community.

We hope it is a message shared by many of you listening today.

“I stand alongside you. Laws and social ignorance about who you are will not diminish your inherent worth and contribution to society. You have allies. You are loved and valued. Be kind to yourself, remembering you are not alone. You are not only welcome in this sacred place, you are celebrated. I will fight with you for your rights and your futures. Embrace who you are, I will walk alongside you.”

Let us hold in our heart all those affected by today’s service.

I will close with what is perhaps Aotearoa’s most well-known whakatauki, followed by a short karakia:

He aha te mea nui o te ao?

He tangata, he tangata, he tangata

What is the most important thing in the world – it’s people, it’s people, it’s people.

Karakia

Tuhia ki te rangi write it in the sky

Tuhia ki te whenua write it on the earth

Tuhia ki te ngākau ō nga tāngata write it in our hearts

Ko te mea nui the most important thing

Ko te aroha is love

Tihei mauri ora it’s agreed

Quick review:

  1. What does TDoR stand for?
  2. How many different genders are named in one North American language/culture? (5)
  3. Is a transwoman a man or a woman? (a woman!)
  4. From the research, what is the youngest age of a child identifying as the gender not assigned at birth? (2)
  5. What does gender dysphoria mean? (Feeling that the gender assigned to you at birth, is not your gender)
  6. What percentage of adults over the age of 15, identified as trans or non-binary at the last NZ census? (Just under 1%, in more inclusive, accepting societies, this figure is 1.5%. That is estimated to be the more accurate figure.)
  7. Name one myth and briefly debunk it: (3 people, 3 prizes)
  8. Fill in the missing word: Transitioning is not changing your gender it is …………….. it. (affirming).

Answers

  1. Transgender Day of Remembrance
  2. (5)
  3. (a woman!)
  4. (2)
  5. (Feeling that the gender assigned to you at birth, is not your gender)
  6. (Just under 1%, in more inclusive, accepting societies, this figure is 1.5%. That is estimated to be the more accurate figure.)
  7. (see main text)
  8. (affirming).

Links